Safe vessel transfers require more than stationary vessels

November 7 ------ An attempt by a crew member to transfer between two vessels without an approved gangway has highlighted the dangers of unsafe access arrangements and the importance of immediate intervention.
According to the International Marine Contractors Association (IMCA), the attempted transfer was visible from both vessel bridges, yet no intervention took place at that stage. Although the act was eventually stopped and no injuries occurred, the incident raises wider concerns about supervision, procedural compliance and the acceptance of unsafe practices during routine maritime operations.
What happened
IMCA describes an incident involving two vessels positioned alongside each other. A crew member attempted to move between the vessels without using an approved gangway or another designated means of access. The unsafe act was subsequently stopped, and the individual was reminded of the company’s requirements for safe access and personnel transfers.
However, IMCA identified a significant concern: the attempted transfer was clearly visible from the bridges of both vessels, but personnel there did not intervene or arrange an appropriate means of access.
The absence of injuries did not mean the operation was safe. Even when vessels appear stationary alongside one another, their relative positions can change unexpectedly due to swell, tides, passing traffic or adjustments to mooring arrangements. Such movement can create serious hazards for personnel attempting to cross between vessels, particularly where there is no secured transfer arrangement. A person could slip, fall into the water or become trapped between the vessels.
The incident therefore represents a near miss in which an unsafe transfer was prevented before an injury occurred, but important protective measures had already failed.
What went wrong
IMCA identified the normalization of unsafe practices as one of the main factors behind the incident.
The apparent stability of the two vessels contributed to an underestimation of the risks involved in crossing between them. However, being alongside another vessel does not eliminate relative movement or provide a safe means of access.
The company’s procedures required approved access arrangements, but these requirements were not followed. More importantly, the situation exposed a gap between the existence of safety procedures and their practical enforcement. The attempted transfer was visible to personnel on both bridges, yet the required intervention did not take place. IMCA highlighted this as a failure of supervision and safety ownership.
This distinction is important. The issue was not limited to an individual attempting an unsafe transfer. It also concerned the wider vessel teams’ responsibility to recognize hazardous behavior, challenge it and ensure that safe arrangements were available. The incident illustrates how an unsafe act can become accepted when those observing it fail to intervene, particularly during activities perceived as routine.
The big picture: When unsafe practices become accepted
Personnel transfers are familiar activities across shipping and offshore operations, but familiarity can lead crews to underestimate hazards that remain present. The absence of an approved gangway can create pressure to improvise, particularly where vessels are already alongside and the distance between them appears manageable. However, a transfer that seems straightforward can become dangerous within seconds if the vessels move unexpectedly.
Similar concerns have emerged in previous maritime incidents. In an earlier IMCA case involving unsafe personnel embarkation, a diver and a supervisor fell into the water while attempting to board a pilot boat without suitable access arrangements. The investigation highlighted the failure to exercise stop-work authority.
Another incident involving a pilot attempting to disembark before a vessel was securely moored demonstrated how quickly an apparently simple transfer can result in a person falling between a vessel and the quayside.
The wider lesson concerns the effectiveness of supervision and the willingness to challenge unsafe practices. A safe system of work depends not only on having procedures, but also on ensuring that personnel intervene when those procedures are bypassed.
What could have reduced the risk?
IMCA emphasizes that personnel must never transfer between vessels unless an approved means of access is available and properly arranged.
For operators and vessel crews, several practical considerations follow from the incident:
• Verify safe access before transfer: Both vessel teams should confirm that an approved and suitable transfer arrangement is available before personnel approach the transfer point.
• Treat vessel movement as an ongoing hazard: Even vessels alongside one another can move independently. Transfer planning must account for environmental conditions, traffic and mooring arrangements.
• Ensure clear supervision: Bridge teams and vessel leadership should establish who is responsible for confirming that access arrangements are safe and that personnel transfers are authorized.
• Intervene immediately: Any crew member observing an unsafe transfer attempt should challenge the activity and ensure it is stopped until safe arrangements are established.
• Avoid informal alternatives: If the approved means of access is unavailable, the transfer should be postponed rather than replaced by an improvised method.
These considerations reinforce the importance of effective communication between vessels, clearly understood responsibilities and the consistent application of company safety procedures. They also demonstrate why stop-work authority must be practical and actively supported, rather than simply documented in a safety management system.
Source: safety4sea.com





Comments